Score: 10

"Not very painful to listen to"

submission: Those Painful Goodbyes

date: December 14, 2009

Well I had to listen to this after that shameless plug :) Only kidding, I do see similarities in our style and I'm glad you mentioned it. I particularly liked the section from around 3:20 - 4:50 which featured the bells, beautiful work and really portrayed the emotions I know you were trying to get across. Looking forward to hearing more of your stuff, keep it up!

Conor.

Score: 10

"Spot on"

submission: An Eternal Destiny

date: November 29, 2009

Excellent job, really liked the middle part, nice gradual buildup to the beat and flows consistently throughout. The choice of sounds are spot on particularly the beat in the mid section. Look forward to hearing more of your work.

Score: 9

"Works really well"

submission: leaving on a sunday

date: November 29, 2009

This piece works really well for a couple of reasons. The main one being that you have created a visual mood and this is very important for pieces like these where there are no vocals. The other reason is that the piece never loses the interest of the listener, that's how I felt, I loved the middle section particularly. Well executed and would be perfect for a dark animation, I can visualize it already! Best of luck. Conor.

Score: 7

"nice but lose the percussion and voice"

submission: KJ - Over the Horizon

date: November 29, 2009

really impressed by the first minute or so, really gripping chord sequence and well executred but all your good work was undone the second that marching drum came in. The vocal choir likewise is too artificial sounding and can be lost altoghether, I think you could have a good piece here if you lose those pieces, perhaps look at adding some strings/violin instead. Good work mate.

Score: 10

"excellent stuff"

submission: .christ is a computer.

date: November 5, 2009

Really nicely done here, solid beat throughout, the drums and percussion were beautifully crafted into the song. Feeling very relaxed after that, keep it up!

Score: 7

"Decent Track"

submission: Melancholy Suite

date: February 20, 2009

Nice work! This sort of style doesn't really appeal to me, but I can still appreciate the effort and thought, not to mention the talent that went into this track, you obviously have a flair for this, so don't stop making music.

Some softer instruments would have been nicer, but maybe that's not the sound you were looking for. You incorporated different phases into the track, but to me, these phases all too similar, there wasn't one moment in the track which stood out as different from the rest, thats not to say it's a bad track, it's just my personal opinion and what I would have liked to hear. Nice work on the drums too, very well done. Keep it up!

7/10

Score: 10

"A beautiful piece from a talented composer"

submission: Siempre (Always)

date: January 17, 2009

Hi Marky, this is really brilliant stuff. I loved the piece. it has a really natural flow to and it could really do well in a movie or tv show, it's beautiful. All the best with your future work.

Score: 9

"Nice work"

submission: Flimbiano

date: January 9, 2009

Hey I really liked this, perhaps some of my judgment is biased for nostalgic reasons as I played Flimbo's quest religiously when I young so it's nice to hear it again. Putting that aside though, you have done a really nice job on applying a nice relaxing ambient feel to the tune, it's well constructed and flows, i especially like the bells you added. Well done.

Score: 10

"Respect and all that"

submission: Frequency Overload

date: January 4, 2009

Brilliant! loved the piano sounded really fresh and original, you are obviously very talented.
The piano in the middle was excellent, really made me sit up and appreciate the work and thought gone into this tune. keep it up

Score: 10

"Well crafted"

submission: Guitar Vs. Piano 1.2

date: December 23, 2008

Loved it! original and executed to near perfection